Sausage Pie Recipe - with Apples - Butter & Baggage (2024)

Home » Recipes » » Sausage Pie

Published: Aug 3, 2015 · Modified: Dec 21, 2021 by Barbara Curry · This post may contain affiliate links.

Disclaimer: This post may contain affiliate links.

This sausage pie recipe is not only great for breakfast or brunch but is hearty enough for dinner. A dish all will enjoy and even heats up great for leftovers. A showstopper for your next brunch or relaxing weekend breakfast featuring a savory dish with a bit of sweet from fresh apples.

While it’s not officially apple season, winter apples are always available and work great in this apple and sausage pie. It seems like I love anything with Italian sausage, and this recipe is no exception. I just wasn’t sure if the girls would like it. One isn’t a cheese fan and the other claims to hate ricotta.

The non-cheese lover, still loved this, she just didn’t eat as much of the topping. The ricotta hater, decided she didn’t mind ricotta when it was melted and mixed with other cheeses. Another success!

Why you’ll love this sausage pie recipe

• You don’t expect apples to compliment the Italian sausage so well, but you won’t be able to clean your plate fast enough!
• This is a hearty meal perfect for breakfast, brunch or brinner.
• A ready to bake pie crust makes the turn around time on this dish minimal – more time with family and enjoying your meal.

What you’ll need

• Pie crust – you can use a fresh or frozen pie crust
• Apples– Fuji makes a great choice in this dish because it’s firm and not overly sweet.
• Onion– I used a sweet onion for this dish
• Italian sausage– be sure to remove the casing, you can use sweet or hot, whichever you prefer.
• Cheese blend – I used a delicious mix of shredded fontina,asiago and provolone. You can substitute, but you should include at least one melty cheese like fontina or provolone.
• Ricotta cheese – this soft, white curd cheese mixes in perfectly with the egg and cheeses
• Eggs, garlic, butter, sugar

If you don’t have a pie crust in your freezer, you’ll need to plan ahead and make one or pick up a prepared one from the grocery. The homemade ones are so much better, but I realize everyone may not want to take the time to make one. When I use a homemade crust recipe, this flaky butter crust is a perfect go-to option.

What is Ricotta Cheese

Ricotta cheese is a light, slightly sweet cheese that is made from what is leftover when making other cheeses. It’s technically a whey cheese, which means it is made from the liquid that’s leftover when making regular cheese. It has the consistency of cottage cheese but with a sweeter taste.

It can be made from Cow, sheep or buffalo, but what we see most in the States comes from cow’s milk. If you have an Italian market handy, the ricotta you find their is amazing. Otherwise, I use a full fat brand from the grocery.

How do you make this sausage pie recipe

Step 1

Start by pre-baking a pie crust.Pre-baking keeps the crust from getting soggy.

Step 2

Sauté the apples and onions with a little sugar and once softened add garlic. Remove from the skillet and add the Italian sausage to the same skillet and brown it.

Step 3

Combine eggs, cheese and ricotta.

Variation: You can add a half teaspoon each of paprika and parsley to your cheese mixture or sprinkle it on top.

Step 4

Layer the sausage on the bottom of the pre-baked pie crust. Next add the apple layer and top with the cheese mixture and bake.

Pro tip: If you don’t like ricotta cheese, you can substitute cottage cheese as another option.

The apples and sausage are just perfect together, I used sweet Italian sausage, but if you want to be more adventurous, try a spicy variety. The apples will help cool things down to offset the heat.

I was afraid with the eggs that this would be quiche like, which wasn’t what I wanted. You will find that it is nothing like quiche; the eggs just help hold the cheese together. While not quiche like, we decided it would still be great for brunch. I find that I make this anytime I have left over ricotta like when I make spaghetti alla vodka.

More breakfast ideas

Adapted from Simply Recipes

If you loved this recipe, give it a star ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ rating! Also, snap a picture of your finished dish and share it with me onInstagramusing the hashtag #butterandbaggage and tagging me @butterandbaggage.